Skip to main content

Court Case Apple ๐Ÿ†š Epic; Apple defends App Store control in court, saying it doesn’t want to be Like Android.



KEY POINTS
  • Epic Games argued that Apple purposely locks in its customers in the first day of a landmark trial with Apple over the rules of the App Store.
  • Apple is arguing that it built the App Store and gets to set the rules — which are designed to ensure that apps are high quality and secure.
  • On Monday, Apple’s and Epic’s lawyers both made their opening statements, and Epic Games founder and CEO Tim Sweeney testified.

In this article

Tim Sweeney, chief executive officer of Epic Games Inc., arrives at U.S. district court in Oakland, California, U.S., on Monday, May, 3, 2021.
Tim Sweeney, chief executive officer of Epic Games Inc., arrives at U.S. district court in Oakland, California, U.S., on Monday, May, 3, 2021.
David Paul Morris | Bloomberg | Getty Images

Epic Games argued that Apple purposely locks in its customers in the first day of a landmark trial with Apple over the rules of the App Store.

Epic is looking to force Apple to open up iPhone software distribution so it could use its own payment processor, bypassing Apple’s customary 30% fee on digital goods. A favorable ruling could even allow Epic to offer its own app store for iPhones.

Apple is arguing that it built the App Store and gets to set the rules, which are designed to ensure that apps are high quality and secure.

“Epic wants us to be Android, but we don’t want to be. And our consumers don’t want that either. They want the choice,” Apple lawyer Karen Dunn said.

Epic’s argument is that Apple’s App Store is anti-competitive, and that its arguments about quality and security are essentially an excuse to exclude competitors like Epic Games’ title Fortnite, which was booted from Apple’s store last year after it introduced a direct payment mechanism.

On Monday, Apple’s and Epic’s lawyers both made their opening statements, and Epic Games founder and CEO Tim Sweeney testified. The trial is expected to last three weeks.

Walled garden

A core part of the debate centers around the relevant market that Apple allegedly dominates.

Epic is arguing that the relevant market is iPhone app distribution. Apple says it is game distribution, and that users can easily switch to other phones and game consoles.

To bolster its definition, Epic is trying to show how Apple works to lock users into its products, making it more difficult to switch to Android or other platforms. On Monday, Epic lawyers cited several internal Apple documents, some over a decade old, while arguing that Apple executives built a “walled garden” brick by brick.

“Getting customers using our stores (iTunes, App, and iBookstore) is one of the best things we can do to get people hooked into the ecosystem,” Eddy Cue, current Apple online services senior vice president, wrote to Apple CEO Tim Cook in 2013, according to an email revealed by Epic Games.

“Who leaves Apple products once they’ve bought apps, music, movies, etc!” Cue concluded.

In another exchange, Apple executives discussed in 2013 whether releasing a version of iMessage for Android would make it easier to switch phone brands. iMessage is still exclusive to Apple products.

“I am concerned that the iMessage on Android would simply serve to remove and obstacle to iPhone families giving their kids Android phones,” Craig Federighi, Apple software senior vice president, wrote in 2013.

In 2016, a customer emailed Apple saying that iMessage amounts to “serious lock-in.” As part of an internal conversation about that email, Apple’s current head of marketing, Greg Joswiak, wrote to colleagues, “we hear this a lot.”

Most recently, Federighi wrote to Cook about Apple’s sign-in feature which enables users to log into apps with an Apple login, saying that the feature is likely to “make our platform more sticky” in 2019.

Epic also argued that Apple doesn’t need the App Store approval process to keep iPhone users safe. Epic contended that because Apple has sometimes approved low-quality apps for the store, its approval process is ineffective and doesn’t protect user security.

In an email produced as part of proceedings, former Apple marketing boss Phil Schiller wrote in 2012 “Is no one minding the store? This is insane!!!!!!!” in response to a report of an “obvious rip off” app becoming the top free app on Apple’s platform.

Apple doesn’t want to be Android

Apple Fellow Phil Schiller arrives at federal court on May 03, 2021 in Oakland, California.
Apple Fellow Phil Schiller arrives at federal court on May 03, 2021 in Oakland, California.
Justin Sullivan | Getty Images

In Apple’s opening statement, it emphasized that its rules have helped created a vibrant ecosystem that benefits iPhone developers, with more than 1.8 million apps in the App Store.

Apple said that Epic made $750 million from the App Store, arguing that the trial is merely about money and that Epic planned this lawsuit and a related marketing campaign in order to use Apple’s technology without paying. Apple also said that Epic was looking at the wrong market and cannot show anti-competitive conduct in the gaming market — users can switch to Android, Microsoft Xbox or Sony Playstation.

Apple also defended its “walled garden” without using those terms, citing its App Review department that manually reviews and approves apps and filters out “obviously malicious apps.” It said that based on its research, iOS represents only 2% of malware infections among all computing platforms.

“Take away from the security particular to the iPhones and the bad actors have a field day. This is why Android security statistics are so much worse,” Dunn said.

“We thought about the fact that the iPhone is a phone that you’re carrying around, you need it to work for you as a phone, and we cared deeply about the security of that device so it would be more protected and more reliable than PCs were at the time,” Apple cited Schiller saying.

That’s why Apple doesn’t allow “sideloading,” or manual installation of apps, like Android does, Apple argued. If Epic wins, Apple contended, it would mean a less secure iPhone operating system.

What’s the App Store margin?

In its opening argument, Epic lawyers said that Apple’s App Store generates large profits, with operating margins of 78% in 2019 and 75% in 2018.

Epic cited Ned Barnes, one of its expert witnesses, who says he used internal Apple documents to come up with the calculation.

The profitability of Apple’s App Store will be part of Epic’s argument that Apple uses its market power to extract excess fees from software developers.

“We have documents, long detailed PowerPoints prepared for Apple’s senior executive team that lay out the profitability of the App Store in regular presentations given multiple years in a row,” Epic lawyer Katherine Forrest said.

Apple disputes the accuracy of the number and has said that the company doesn’t look at profit and loss for specific units, instead looking at Apple’s financials on a higher level.

“They’re going to pull documents out of context in this case. This is incredibly misleading,” said Apple lawyer Dunn. She said in court Monday that Apple doesn’t internally allocate to the App Store the costs of building the technology for the store, and that the company has an integrated business model.

“Apple is concerned that analysts, investors, reporters, and others in the marketplace could misinterpret the public disclosure of non-public, unaudited financial information,” Apple lawyers previously wrote in a court filing.

Apple’s App Store is part of Apple’s services business, which executives have highlighted to investors as a source of growth. Apple reported $53.77 billion in sales in its services line in its fiscal 2020 with a 66% gross margin (its fiscal year ended Sept. 26, 2020). Apple’s services sales also includes subscriptions like Apple Music, AppleCare warranties and licensing fees in addition to the App Store.


#CNBC


@cnbc


#osutayusuf


@osutayusuf

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Escaped Murder Suspect Finally Arrested in Yumbe Regional Referral Hospital, Yumbe District.

Story by Osuta Yusuf. 19-November-2024. ๐Ÿ“ธ: Eyotre Kennedy handcuffed on bed while receiving medication this morning at Yumbe Regional Referral Hospital in Yumbe District. Eyotre Kennedy originating from Etoko village, Nyoroo Parish, Nyadri Sub-county in Maracha District who has for many years been terrorizing residents in his village, has finally been arrested this Monday morning 19-November-2024 while receiving treatment at Yumbe Regional Referral Hospital in Yumbe District following injuries he sustained from Theft mission on Saturday night 16-November-2024 in Owapi village, Azapi parish in Odupi Sub-county, Terego East Constituency in Terego District. Click here on the link  https://informationispowah.blogspot.com/2024/11/fugitive-who-chopped-3-people-killed.html   to read the story on his Theft of Goats in Terego. Upon getting cut on the finger and leg by the Mob as he attempted to fight and overpower owner of the goats he attempted to steal on Saturday night ...

41-Years-Old Man Digs His Own Grave in Maracha District.

Story by Osuta Yusuf.  Maracha District.  ๐Ÿ“ธ: The grave been dug by Mr Opiga Michael, a victim of frustration. Photo taken by Osuta Yusuf , on Wednesday 11-September-2024. The residents of Ebapi village, Baria Parish in Nyadri Sub-county, Maracha east constituency, Maracha District are in shock after a 41 year old man started digging his own grave. The man, identified as Mr Opiga Michael, who seems to be frustrated over some challenges in life, started digging his own grave on Tuesday 10-September-2024 until he was stopped by the elders in Nyaria clan. ๐Ÿ“ธ: Opiga Michael, the Victim of Frustration. Photo by Osuta Yusuf , Information is Power. While speaking to our reporter on Wednesday evening 11-September-2024, Mr Opiga Michael, said, his main plan  was to commit suicide after finishing digging the grave for burying himself, explained that, he feels frustrated, abandoned and hated by his own clan people, whom he accused of piling lies against him a...

Wedded Ayivu West MP Lematia John Fights Over Another Woman.

  ๐Ÿ“ธ: Hon Lematia John. By URN. Police in Arua district are investigating a case of assault and threatening violence involving the Member of Parliament for Ayivu West Constituency John Lematia and James Ariko, a DSTV technician in Arua city. Drama ensued on Easter Sunday 31-3-2024 at Dream Land Hotel located at Kuluva trading center along Arua-Nebbi highway in Arua district when the legislator and the technician engaged in a fight reportedly over a woman identified as Faith Eyotaru 25, a relationship officer at Victoria University Kampala. The scuffle started after Ayivu West Mp John Lematia went to swim at Dreamland Hotel with Faith Eyotaru only to find Ariko, who had gone to the same hotel earlier. However, upon seeing the duo coming out of the vehicle, Ariko confronted Lematia with both men claiming to be having a relationship with the lady. It took the intervention of the staff at the hotel who intervened and separated the fight between the men. Josephine Angucia, the West Nil...